Kit vs Substack vs beehiiv vs Mailchimp: The Real Fees, Compared (2026)
Kit vs Substack vs beehiiv vs Mailchimp, compared by what each one actually takes: Substack's '10%' is really ~13.6% with processing, Kit breaks even at about $390/month of paid revenue, and Mailchimp's free tier ends at 250 contacts. Checked against official pricing pages on November 15, 2026.
Disclosure: This site participates in affiliate programs, including the Kit Affiliate Program, and may earn a commission when you sign up through a link on this page, at no additional cost to you. Read the full disclosure. All prices and fees below were checked against each provider's official pricing pages on November 15, 2026. Estimates are labeled as estimates.
The short version
We expected Substack's 10% to be the expensive option and Kit's $39 to be the cheap one. Then we added up everything Substack actually takes — the 10% platform fee, Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30, and 0.7% for Stripe Billing — and the real number is about 13.6% of every payment. That changed the answer.
Break-even: at roughly $390/month in paid subscription revenue, Kit Creator ($39/month + 3.5% per transaction) becomes cheaper than Substack (about 13.6% of revenue, including processing). Checked November 15, 2026.
Fees at a glance
- Kit — Monthly fee: $39/mo (Creator, up to 1,000 subscribers). Takes: 3.5% + $0.30 per transaction, card processing included. Free plan: up to 10,000 subscribers.
- Substack — Monthly fee: $0. Takes: 10% platform fee + 2.9% + $0.30 Stripe processing + 0.7% Stripe Billing (≈13.6% + $0.30). Free plan: — (publishing is free; fees apply to paid subscriptions).
- beehiiv — Monthly fee: $0 Free / $49/mo Lite / $95/mo Pro (1,000-subscriber tier, annual billing). Takes: 0% on paid plans (+ Stripe 2.9% + $0.30). Free plan: up to 2,500 subscribers.
- Mailchimp — Monthly fee: $0 Free / from $13/mo (Essentials, 500 contacts). Takes: — (no per-sale cut). Free plan: 250 contacts, 500 sends/month.
How each tool actually charges you: fees and pricing, tool by tool
Kit (formerly ConvertKit) — flat fee, plus a small cut on every plan
Creator starts at $39/month for up to 1,000 subscribers and scales with list size (annual billing gives two months free). The free plan allows up to 10,000 subscribers. When you sell something — a paid subscription or a product — Kit takes 3.5% + $0.30 per transaction on every plan, including the paid ones. That fee already includes card processing, which Kit points out means its own cut is about 0.6%.
Substack — no monthly fee, 10% forever (plus processing)
Publishing is free and there is no monthly bill. Substack takes 10% of every subscription payment. On top of that you pay Stripe's card processing (2.9% + $0.30) and Stripe Billing (0.7% on recurring payments). Real total: about 13.6% + $0.30 of every payment, for as long as you stay.
beehiiv — 0% cut, higher flat fee
beehiiv takes 0% of paid-subscription and digital-product revenue on its paid plans; you only pay Stripe's standard 2.9% + $0.30. The catch: paid subscriptions are a paid-plan feature. Plans are Free (up to 2,500 subscribers), Lite at $49/month and Pro at $95/month at the 1,000-subscriber tier on annual billing, checked November 15, 2026 (month-to-month costs more). One detail we caught while checking: beehiiv renamed its plans recently — older comparisons still list 'Scale' and 'Max,' which no longer exist. The current names are Free, Lite, and Pro.
Mailchimp — the free tier is a sample size
Mailchimp's free plan stops at 250 contacts, with sending capped at 500 emails a month. The cheapest paid plan, Essentials, starts at $13/month for 500 contacts. Mailchimp is built for email marketing campaigns; for a paid newsletter business, most creators outgrow the free tier before they finish setting up.
The break-even math (estimates)
Using the official fees above, and setting aside the $0.30 per-transaction fee that every option charges in some form:
- Around $390/month in paid revenue, Substack's roughly 13.6% total reaches about $53 — the same as Kit Creator at that revenue ($39 + 3.5%). Past this point Substack costs more than Kit every month, and the gap grows with revenue. (Our estimate.)
- At $500/month: Substack ≈ $68, beehiiv Lite ≈ $63.50, Kit ≈ $56.50. Kit is the cheapest of the three at this size. (Estimate, from the fees above.)
- At $1,000/month: Substack ≈ $136, beehiiv Lite ≈ $78, Kit ≈ $74 — until your list grows enough to push Kit into a higher pricing tier. (Estimate.)
We haven't paid any of these bills yet — this site is new, and our list is still small. What we did do is read all four official pricing pages on the same day and run the arithmetic in the open, so you can check it. Your real numbers will move with subscriber count, churn, and how many small transactions you process — each one adds $0.30 somewhere.
The thing nobody puts in the pricing table: leaving
Every tool here lets you export email addresses. What does not travel is your paid subscribers' billing. If you build a paid list on Substack and later move, subscribers typically have to sign up and pay again on the new platform — and some never do. That is the real lock-in, and it is why the fee question matters before you have revenue, not after. It's also why this site exists: followers are rented, and a paid list built on someone else's billing is rented twice over.
Kit's weaknesses, honestly
- The price went up: Creator rose from $29 to $39/month in September 2025, and the price keeps rising with your list size. A big list on Kit is not cheap.
- The 3.5% transaction fee applies on paid plans too. beehiiv's 0% beats it on this line.
- Tiered pricing means your bill grows automatically as you succeed. Substack's percentage, for all its cost, never sends you a bigger fixed bill in a slow month.
So which one?
- Starting from zero, no revenue yet: Kit free (10,000 subscribers) or beehiiv free (2,500) let you grow before paying. Substack if you want zero setup and don't mind the percentage later.
- Paid newsletter earning over roughly $390/month: Kit is usually cheapest — run your own numbers with the fees above.
- You want 0% taken and expect fast growth: beehiiv Lite or Pro — budget the flat fee.
- You mainly send marketing campaigns, not a paid newsletter: Mailchimp — but know the free tier ends at 250 contacts.
FAQ
Is Substack really 10%?
The platform fee is 10%. With Stripe processing (2.9% + $0.30) and Stripe Billing (0.7%), the effective total is about 13.6% + $0.30 per payment.
Kit or Substack: which is cheaper?
Below roughly $390/month in paid revenue, Substack costs less because there is no monthly fee. Above it, Kit is cheaper, and the gap widens as revenue grows (estimate from official fees, November 15, 2026).
What does Substack take from a $10/month subscription?
About $1.66 of each $10 payment: $1.00 platform fee, $0.29 + $0.30 Stripe processing, and $0.07 Stripe Billing.
Does Kit charge fees on top of the monthly price?
Yes — 3.5% + $0.30 per transaction when you sell subscriptions or products, on every plan. That fee includes card processing.
Can I move my list later?
Email addresses export anywhere. Paid subscribers' payment details do not move with you; expect some loss if you migrate a paid list.
Checked against official pricing pages on November 15, 2026 (Kit, Substack, beehiiv, Mailchimp). Prices change; if a number here looks stale, tell us — corrections are part of the point. Read more about this site.
Discussion
No comments yet